Job search
Job Search

Is the grass always greener?

The use of synthetic turf in football continues to generate much debate, particularly with the growing interest from professional clubs. SAPCA CEO Chris Trickey offers guidance on its development, performance standards and long-term benefits

by Chris Trickey, SAPCA | Published in Sports Management 2012 issue 1

Synthetic turf pitches could be making a shock comeback if some Football League clubs get their way. The debate has begun to heat up following a decision by clubs such as Wycombe and Accrington to investigate reintroducing synthetic turf pitches. A subsequent Sky Sports debate called Turf Wars fuelled the debate and all 72 Football League clubs are now being asked to discuss the issue in three divisional meetings.

SAPCA, the trade body that represents sports and play facility construction in the UK, helps the sector to separate the facts from the myths regarding this contentious subject.

Myth – Artificial turf pitches are hard and plastic
The most significant change over the last decade has been the much greater use of ‘third generation’ or 3G synthetic grass surfaces, using relatively long-pile, and very sophisticated, yarns with rubber and sand in-fills. These surfaces have been developed to replicate the playing performance of high-quality natural turf surfaces and have become very popular for both football and rugby. Needless to say, they perform very much better than the old sand-filled surfaces installed at a number of professional football clubs in the 1980s.

There have been very significant advances in the yarns and fibres used for synthetic turf surfaces. There is now a much wider range of yarns available, with different profiles, shapes and thicknesses, which make it easier to achieve the playing performance needed for individual sports, and with greater consistency. Fibres are now also more durable, enabling surfaces to achieve longer life expectancy.

Myth – Natural turf is always better
The choice of surface is sometimes presented as a battle between natural and synthetic turf, but few would argue that most players would prefer to play on a top quality natural pitch, if they can. FIFA’s Quality Concept (see box out) seeks to promote football turf mainly in regions where the climate makes it impossible to play matches on good natural turf all year round.

A quick look at old footage from Match of the Day will highlight that the quality of natural turf pitches at the top level of the game has improved dramatically over recent years and are a great credit to the groundsmen working on them, but the demand for synthetic turf in the UK will continue to be led by football clubs and other facilities where there is a practical requirement for more intensive usage – for football and other activities – and a need to boost revenue, to help to ensure financial viability. It is inevitable that the argument for synthetic pitches to be used at all levels of football will continue and eventually there will be more regular use of 3G surfaces in the professional game.

Myth – Players get more injuries on synthetic grass pitches
In research undertaken among 290 players from 10 elite European football clubs and more than 200 players from the Swedish Premier League, the incidence of injury during training and match play was no higher on artificial turf than on natural grass!

Myth – Artificial turf pitches don’t need maintaining
If only this were true! In the very early days of synthetic turf surfaces they were often poorly maintained. However, all artificial grass pitches do need some routine maintenance and these costs should be included within the project budget.

Where clients do not have the expertise or willingness to undertake routine turf maintenance, the pitch contractor or other specialist maintenance companies can provide a professional service.

SAPCA represents suppliers of both natural and artificial grass pitches and has further information at www.sapca.org.uk about both options. SAPCA also has Codes of Practice for both the construction and maintenance of both synthetic and natural turf pitches – recommended reads for anyone considering specifying, buying, operating or maintaining such sports facilities.

FIFA Quality Concept for Football Turf

The game of football in particular has been quick to recognise the benefits of the new synthetic surfaces.

Both UEFA and FIFA took a keen interest when the first 3G surfaces appeared on the market and in 2001 FIFA launched its ‘Quality Concept’ for what it termed ‘football turf’. In 2004, the International Football Association Board decided to include football turf in the Laws of the Game. This allowed matches between national teams (whose associations were FIFA members) and international matches between club teams to be officially staged on artificial turf.

At the heart of FIFA’s Quality Concept are performance standards for football turf. The international body has used test results, player surveys, medical research and information from the industry to develop its own standards, with the aim of satisfying the most rigorous demands in professional football and further improving the playing conditions and safety of artificial turf pitches.

The International Rugby Board (IRB) has also embraced the use of synthetic turf in the official laws and regulations for the sport, allowing the use of synthetic surfaces that comply with the IRB Artificial Rugby Turf Performance Specification, alongside the permitted playing of the game on grass, clay, sand and snow.

Barcelona FC forward Lionel Messi plays on synthetic 
FIFA football turf / PIC: ©www.shutterstock.com
Barcelona FC forward Lionel Messi plays on synthetic FIFA football turf/ PIC: ©www.shutterstock.com
Sign up for FREE ezines

Company profile

Company profile: Precor
Precor has been a pioneer in delivering fitness experiences for commercial customers for more than 40 years and our products and services span all major categories, including cardio, strength, functional fitness, group training, and connected solutions.
View full profile >
More company profiles

Featured Supplier

Sprung Gym-Flooring: leading fitness flooring provider paves the way for top performance
Introducing Sprung Gym-Flooring, where innovation meets excellence in the world of flooring and sports solutions.
View full details >
More featured suppliers

Property & Tenders

Location: Loughton, IG10
Company: Knight Frank
Location: Grantham, Leicestershire
Company: Belvoir Castle
Location: Verwood, Dorset
Company: AVISON YOUNG
Location: Hall Place House, Bexley, DA5 1PQ
Company: London Borough of Bexley
Location: 15 Concessions across the nation's forests
Company: Forestry England
More properties & tenders

Diary dates

11-14 Apr 2024
Exhibition Centre , Cologne, Germany
22-24 Apr 2024
Galgorm Resort, York
10-12 May 2024
China Import & Export Fair Complex, Guangzhou, China
23-24 May 2024
Large Hall of the Chamber of Commerce (Erbprinzenpalais), Wiesbaden, Germany
More diary dates