Job search
Job Search

Leisure centres: Duncan Wood-Allum on the future commissioning and delivery of leisure services

In response to our Talking Point: ‘Are councils asking too much of contract operators?’ and our editor’s letter on the same topic, Duncan Wood-Allum, managing director of SLC, shares his thoughts on the future commissioning and delivery of leisure services

Published in Sports Management 2018 issue 3
Read on turning pages | Download PDF of this issue
Duncan Wood-Allum is managing director of consultancy SLC
Duncan Wood-Allum is managing director of consultancy SLC

The leisure operating market has never been in such a dynamic state of flux. Continued austerity, major budget cuts and polarisation of political philosophies on how services should be run all add to an environment where, more than ever, leisure operators have to be on their toes.

In the Sports Management Talking Point, a number of operators and advisors shared their views on whether the market had overheated and councils were demanding too much from their contracts.

The article was right to note that in some instances, councils (which sometimes take the wrong advice or do not take any advice) are seeing leisure contracts as cash generators only, rather than a sustainable market intervention to contribute to a number of wider strategic outcomes.

With borough treasurers putting the pressure on councils to find savings, revenue-positive leisure contracts can be seen as a potential ‘easy win’. However, I believe council officers and members should establish a joined-up approach to commissioning, identify their community’s needs, facility requirements and investment opportunities, and set sensible and achievable affordability levels. They then have the option to select the optimal management model – often over a period of two to four years before procurement – to enable them to achieve both their financial goals and deliver significant social value.

A broader role
A key factor missing in the article was the broader strategic role of leisure in contributing to agendas such as adult social care, regeneration, economic development, placemaking and social cohesion. Leisure cannot continue to try to justify itself for its own sake – it needs to co-create local solutions to bigger issues that can act as a catalyst for partnership working, combine funding through joint commissioning, and leverage investment from regeneration. This can often lead to co-location of new facilities with other functions and services, making better use of scarce resources.

The transformation of our town centres and cityscapes is paving the way from a retail-based core to a mixed economy of retail, leisure, community, commercial and housing. This creates huge opportunities for developing new models to support people’s changing lifestyles, health and wellbeing needs. Local authorities have an opportunity to leverage the expertise of the leisure sector to bring investment that will inject life and atmosphere back into these town centres. But I’m not convinced anyone in our sector has fully clocked onto this huge opportunity yet.

The experts commenting in the Sports Management article indicated that there are two core income streams – gym memberships and swimming lessons. In my view, this is missing a huge opportunity and reinforcing a myth.

Adapting the offer
Those operators that are succeeding in developing new revenue streams are leading the way, as well as winning and retaining more contracts. These revenue streams can be linked to children’s activities, commissioned health interventions, youth offers, active play and group-based exercise, as well as on-demand fitness and wellbeing classes.

In her editor’s letter, Liz Terry says that “if councils push too hard, they will spawn a whole raft of competition, as management contractors throw in the towel and decide to compete instead”. I believe those operators are the ones that have not adapted and innovated.

Many councils (and most of SLC’s clients) no longer want to work with ‘bog standard’ operators – they’re looking for partners that not only know how to drive an asset commercially, but add wider social value through outreach, innovative approaches to concessions and partnering with other agencies such as Public Health, Adult and Social Care, Children’s Services, Community Safety teams and the voluntary sector.

With increasing interest in in-house services and an aversion to what is deemed to be ‘privatisation’ from a number of Labour administrations, the market needs to take heed of this change by shifting the emphasis to promoting and leading activity beyond the traditional leisure centre setting. More of a ‘Community Activity Contract’ than a ‘Leisure Management Contract’ perhaps?

Good points
Chris Marriott of the Sports Consultancy was right, in his comment, in highlighting the golden period of aggressively bid contracts. Yes – it was close to overheating but has calmed down and operators are being more circumspect in qualifying bids and selecting which ones to compete for, particularly where there is a strong incumbent or where there is no ‘hook’ to add value through a different, innovative approach to service delivery.

Peter Gunn rightly highlighted the weaknesses in some procurement processes and the need for councils to be very clear in their financial and social objectives. Justin Jardine from GLL noted the “forward-thinking” approach by councils that involves setting “affordability thresholds in tenders that are realistic and achievable for operators”.

The trust sector has an opportunity to look at how it could use its collective reach and buying power to provide an alternative to the bigger players, but that will require transformative change that may be resisted by the individual leaders and boards of those trusts.

I understand there are some exciting partnerships being explored in Greater Manchester, which is really encouraging.

The article highlighted a concerning trend from some procurement advisors that are encouraging councils to ‘have their cake and eat it’ as regards to transfer of risk. This has and will result in some contracts not receiving bids. I suggest those councils be wary of advisors that over-promise on financial outcomes. Ultimately, the market dictates the value of a contract and the council sets the conditions and affordability levels for that contract.

Tackling inactivity
One area I was surprised and disappointed not to see more of in the article is the role of councils in providing leisure services Using their legal powers, councils, can provide market interventions the private or voluntary sectors are unable to deliver.

Given the pressing need for the nation’s inactive to get moving and improve their health and quality of life, it’s concerning that many contributors to the article (advisors and operators) overlooked this core reason for local government leisure provision.

Budget gyms will not address the needs of the 70 to 80 per cent that want to move more, make social contacts, improve their mental health and make lifestyle changes.

There is still a huge opportunity for operators to innovate and create deep connections with the communities they serve, regardless of management model, as recently demonstrated by an independent trust, Stockport’s Life Leisure, which secured a publicly tendered leisure contract at Barrow BC, an authority looking for added value, rather than just a leisure operator.

Opportunities to thrive
Carefully considered and planned leisure partnerships with the right investment, linked to the strategic priorities of councils can deliver these objectives and run services at a surplus in many parts of the country. To achieve this, securing political commitment is vital and often takes time. Recent procurements that SLC has supported have demonstrated this with some outstanding examples of achieving both financial outcomes, improved services and enhanced social value. Many of our clients have redirected surpluses back into outreach and targeted interventions, rather than taking a saving.

So, to conclude, I’d like to emphasise that leisure operators can thrive in this challenging environment, by delivering localised solutions effectively, having a sensible balance and allocation of risk, sustainable business plans and investment strategies. Natural selection will play a part, as some of the traditional operators who have failed to see the opportunities presented by the public sector step aside for those that do. Getting it right isn’t easy, but the outcomes for all partners and the communities they serve can be well worth the effort.

Duncan Wood-Allum is managing director of the Sport, Leisure and Culture Consultancy

www.slc.uk.com

01444 459927

duncan@slc.uk.com

Sign up for FREE ezines & magazines
Sports jobs
Everyone Active
featured job

Swimming Teachers

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive hourly rate
Job location: Nationwide

Senior Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £23,894 per annum (40 hours a week pro rata)
Location: Tadworth, Surrey

Senior Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £19,775 per annum
Location: Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, UK

Duty Manager

Legacy Leisure
Salary: Competitive
Location: Backwell, Bristol, UK

Duty Manager

Legacy Leisure
Salary: £18,250 to £19,000 per annum
Location: Bicester, UK

Swimming Teacher

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Stratford-upon-Avon

Gymnastics Coach

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Ashfield, United Kingdom

Gymnastics Coach

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Bristol, United Kingdom

Gymnastics Coach

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Bournemouth, United Kingdom

Gymnastics Coach

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Bristol, United Kingdom
recruiting with sports management

Gymnastics Coach

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Fareham, United Kingdom

Gymnastics Coach

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Yateley, United Kingdom

Facilities Manager

Oxford City Council
Salary: £39,243 to £41,164 per annum (pro-rata for part time)
Location: Oxford, UK

WW Coach

Weight Watchers
Salary: £24 per workshop plus commission
Location: Nationwide, United Kingdom

Team Leader

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Queensway, London, UK

Swimming Teacher - Part Time

Circadian Leisure Trust
Salary: £10.96 - £13.24 per hour
Location: Longwell Green, Bristol, UK

Duty Manager

Wiltshire Council
Salary: £24,223 - £26,220 (inclusive of 10% unsocial hours plussage)
Location: Wiltshire, UK
recruiting with sports management

Head of Football Coaching

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive salary
Location: London, UK

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £18,305 per annum (39 hours pro rata)
Location: North Yorkshire, York, UK

Senior Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £17,977 per annum
Location: Swindon, Wiltshire, UK

Assistant Manager

GLL
Salary: Up To £34,966 PA + 8% Bonus after qualifying
Location: Shepherd's Bush, London, UK

Assistant Manager

GLL
Salary: Up To £34,966 PA + 8% Bonus after qualifying
Location: Notting Hill, London, UK

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £18,305 per annum
Location: Bath, Somerset, Bath, UK

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £18,305 per annum
Location: Abingdon, Oxfordshire, UK
training with sports management

Assistant manager

DPD Coaching
Salary: Competitive
Location: Horsham, UK

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £8.21 per hour
Location: Rugby, Warwickshire, UK

Swimming teacher / assistant manager

DPD Coaching
Salary: Competitive
Location: Horsham, UK

Leisure Centre Manager

Derby City Council
Salary: Grade J £32,878 - £36,876 a year pro rata
Location: Derby, UK

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £10.55 per hour
Location: New Barnet, Barnet, UK

Membership Consultants

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: East Staffordshire District, UK

Duty Manager

Legacy Leisure
Salary: £20,000 per annum
Location: Exeter, UK
lifeguard jobs  personal trainer jobs  swimming teacher jobs  recreation assistant jobs  Gymnastics Coach jobs  apprenticeships jobs  duty manager jobs  Swimming instructor jobs  general manager jobs  Regional Sales Manager jobs  Swim Teacher jobs  assistant manager jobs  assistant general manager jobs  fitness instructor jobs  Customer Services Advisor jobs 
More jobs

Video Gallery

TVS Sports Surfaces
Established in 2009 as a specialist supplier of noise and vibration solutions, The TVS Group has successfully evolved into four key strategic divisions; TVS Sports Surfaces, TVS Gym Flooring, TVS Play Surfaces and TVS Acoustics.
Visit website
More videos

Company profile

Company profile: Rubb Buildings Ltd
Rubb Buildings Ltd designs and manufactures relocatable, semi-permanent and permanent fabric engineered specialist sports buildings.
View full profile >
More company profiles

Featured Supplier

Crown overhaul changing rooms at Saunton Sands spa
Saunton Sands Hotel in Devon, UK, has completed a £2m expansion of its spa and wellness facilities.
View full details >
More featured suppliers

Diary dates

23-25 Jul 2019
Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Centre, Melbourne, Australia
05-06 Sep 2019
TagusPark, Oeiras, Portugal
21-22 Sep 2019
Locations worldwide,
23-26 Sep 2019
JW Marriott Turnberry Resort & Spa, Miami, United States
More diary dates