Job search
Job Search

Pool safety: The role of design in pool safety

The design of a swimming pool can hugely affect the operator’s ability to keep swimmers safe. Tom Walker investigates

by Tom Walker, Leisure Media | Published in Sports Management Jul Aug 2017 issue 132
Designers need to consider the operational and safety requirements of the project / © shutterstock/ Microgen
Designers need to consider the operational and safety requirements of the project/ © shutterstock/ Microgen

There are a number of factors that can either improve or hinder swimming pool safety. Lighting, glare, reflection, blind spots, depth of water and the colour of paints are all aspects that should be taken into consideration during the design process.

Get them right and the result is an operationally efficient environment, which is attractive and safe for swimmers. Get them wrong and you might end up with a poorly designed swimming pool that can be very expensive to manage and keep safe.

“An operator recently opened a pool in the east of England that ordinarily would have required two lifeguards,” says Martyn Symcox, director of water safety management at the Royal Life Saving Society (RLSS). “But when the pool opened, the company was forced to have a third lifeguard on duty in order to make it safe for users.

“The reason was the daylight entering the pool hall, which caused such glare that the lifeguards could only be positioned on one side of the pool – they simply couldn’t view their zone from any other point. Moving just one metre caused the bottom of the pool to become a blind spot. A further blind spot was created by the steps leading to the pool, which did not conform to the basic rectangular shape.

“The pool design resulted in a significant increase in costs for the operator. As well as employing the third lifeguard, they had to apply a specialist film to the building’s glazing to try to limit the glare.”

Reflecting issues
Symcox says there are plenty more examples like this. “It’s not uncommon for operators to find themselves in the position of having to invest in extra staff to manage the challenges caused by the design of the pool,” he says. “It can be extremely expensive.”

So, is there too little focus on safety from those who design the swimming pools?

Mike Hall, a partner at FaulknerBrowns, one of the UK’s leading leisure and swimming pool architects, says that safety should always be at the core of all design decisions. He agrees, however, that there are plenty of examples of style over functionality in the UK currently.

“I’ve seen many sports and leisure projects where insufficient design emphasis has been placed on the operational safety and management of spaces,” Hall says. “In my view, the architect must be able to balance the sometimes conflicting agendas in order to create safe, usable and attractive spaces that help promote swimming.”

According to Hall, the most common design problems at UK pools relate to glare and reflection – and the problems are sometimes linked to inexperience. “Spectral reflection of light from the water is a significant issue,” he says.

“We’ve designed plenty of pools, so we’re acutely aware of the complexities, but I’m not sure that other architects – those with less experience of this building typology – are aware of them.

“I’ve seen a number of pool halls where the introduction of glass has been undertaken without a complete understanding of the consequences for safety or the management of the facility.”

Lines of communication
The view that safety concerns are sometimes overlooked or not properly understood at the design phase is one shared by George Lampshire, regional safety and quality manager for Everyone Active. One of the UK’s largest leisure contractors, Everyone Active currently manages 140 leisure sites on behalf of 40 local authorities.

“An emphasis on safety appears to form a very small part of the design process of new leisure centres,” Lampshire says. “Pools are now designed to be very open plan, with lots of light through huge glazed areas. This can be an issue, due to glare and light reflections, which can impair a lifeguard’s visibility of the pool.”

For RLSS’s Symcox, some of the issues could be prevented with a simple solution – designers and operators talking to each other. “We would encourage architects to meet with pool operators to discuss the design of a swimming pool with regards to both aesthetics and running costs,” he says.

“Increased communication between pool designers, builders and operators at the design stage of the project would go a long way to minimising some of the problems, if not eliminating them entirely. A few architects already do this well and as a result they’re designing and building swimming pools without losing any creativity.

“However, in our experience, some don’t seem to have a grasp of the day-to-day needs of pool operation, which can ultimately result in greater costs.”

Everyone Active’s Lampshire agrees. “There needs to be more engagement with operators during the design process,” he says. “Because what might look good isn’t always the most practical option.”

According to Hall, FaulknerBrowns is one of the architects already actively engaging with operators – but more can be done.

“An essential part of our design process is to obtain feedback from our clients,” he says. “This includes feedback on operational issues, which we use to help improve the operational safety of our facilities.

“But, we would certainly welcome greater cooperation between all parties involved in the delivery of pools to improve the overall standard of safety.”

How do you keep your pools safe?

George Lampshire
George Lampshire
George Lampshire,

Regional Health, Safety and Quality Manager,

Everyone Active


• All sessions across our 140 sites are always supervised by qualified lifeguards

• All lifeguards undergo monthly competence training with a qualified RLSS assessor in order to ensure their skills are kept up-to-date

• We undertake lifeguard zone visibility tests for each lifeguard position and session

• We operate a strict admission policy, and rules for children swimming under the age of eight

• All swimming pool rules are clearly displayed in the pool hall, including signage indicating the pool depth as well as areas for non-swimmers

DESIGNER’S TIPS

Key challenges to consider when designing a safe pool:

Mike Hall
Mike Hall
Mike Hall,

FaulknerBrowns


• Allow for high levels of supervision of the entire pool with no parts hidden from view

• Moderate changes in pool tank floor level in an appropriate way, with no sudden changes in depth and with clear demarcation of edges within the pool

• Design pool surrounds and changing villages without changes in level

• Place shallow water at the point of entry to the pool closest to the changing village

Lifesaving technology

As well as design, another hot topic affecting pool safety is the use of technology. Underwater cameras, movement detectors and other electronic monitoring systems are now being introduced at many pools – and some have already proven their worth.

In 2015, a drowning detection system called Poseidon made national headlines when it helped save the life of a swimmer at the Blackshots Leisure Centre in Essex.

Everyone Active is one of the operators to have embraced assistive technology. “Some of our facilities now have underwater cameras to aid lifeguards in monitoring their allocated zones,” says Lampshire. “In many cases, the technology offers us a 100 per cent view of the bottom of the pool, which could not otherwise be achieved due to the design of the pool hall.”

The RLSS, which trains lifeguards, is enthusiastic about new technologies – but warns that the tech has its limitations. “We support the use of technology where it can help improve safety standards,” says Symcox. “But it’s important to remember that the systems are intended to support lifeguards – not to replace them.”

In 2015, the Poseidon system alerted lifeguards to a motionless body at the bottom of the pool
In 2015, the Poseidon system alerted lifeguards to a motionless body at the bottom of the pool
Sign up for FREE ezines
Sports jobs

Sales, Marketing and Retention Manager

University of Leeds
Salary: £37,099 - £44,263pa + generous pension + benefits
Location: Leeds, UK

Exercise Referral Instructor

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive
Location: Saltburn-by-the-Sea

Epping Forest Keeper (countryside Ranger)

City of London Corporation
Salary: £35,663 - £39,805pa + Local Govt Pension + benefits
Location: Loughton, UK

Aquatics Officer - dual site

Brio Leisure
Salary: from £29,269pa
Location: Northwich, UK

Fitness Manager

Everyone Active
Salary:
Location: Bristol

Climbing Activities and Wellbeing Coordinator

Everyone Active
Salary:
Location: Winchester

Strategic Manager Leisure Partnerships and Health

Swansea Council
Salary: £53,653 – £58,089pa
Location: Swansea, UK

Centre Manager - dual site

Brio Leisure
Salary:  £35,745pa + excellent benefits
Location: Ellesmere Port, UK

Centre Manager - dual site

Brio Leisure
Salary: £35,745pa + excellent benefits
Location: Chester, UK
recruiting with sports management

Activity & Wellbeing Leader

Everyone Active
Salary:
Location: Stratford-upon-Avon

Chief Executive Officer

Redbridge Sports & Leisure
Salary: on request
Location: Barkingside, Ilford, UK

Swimming Teacher

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive rates of pay
Location: Rickmansworth, UK

Swimming Teacher

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive rates of pay
Location: Watford, UK
Swimming Teacher jobs  duty manager jobs  Team Leader jobs  Swim Manager jobs  general manager jobs  recreation assistant jobs 
More jobs

Company profile

Company profile: Everyone Active
Everyone Active's aim is to get communities active, engaged and entertained through our wide-ranging activities and services that include, sports, coaching, culture, events, health and happiness. We manage a vast range of indoor and outdoor facilities including swimming pools, spas, sports halls, squash courts, studios, fitness suites, climbing walls, cafes, golf courses, athletics stadia and sports pitches.
View full profile >
More company profiles

Featured Supplier

Explosion of passion for fitness at RiminiWellness 2024 and record success for Panatta
The passion for fitness and bodybuilding reached new heights at the Panatta stands during RiminiWellness (30 May – 2 June 20204) – the largest fitness event in Italy – which this year exceeded the 100,000 visitor mark.
View full details >
More featured suppliers

Property & Tenders

Location: Cleveland Lakes, Wiltshire and Gloucestershire
Company: Cotswold Lakes Trust
Location: Loughton, IG10
Company: Knight Frank
Location: Grantham, Leicestershire
Company: Belvoir Castle
Location: Hall Place House, Bexley, DA5 1PQ
Company: London Borough of Bexley
Location: 15 Concessions across the nation's forests
Company: Forestry England
More properties & tenders

Diary dates

03-05 Sep 2024
IMPACT Exhibition Center, Bangkok, Thailand
08-10 Sep 2024
Wyndham® Lake Buena Vista Disney Springs™ Resort, Lake Buena Vista, United States
19-19 Sep 2024
The Salil Hotel Riverside - Bangkok, Bangkok 10120, Thailand
20-22 Sep 2024
Locations worldwide,
More diary dates