Job search
Job Search

Talking point: Are councils asking too much of leisure centre contract operators?

As a number of large sport and leisure contracts come up for renewal and with councils putting ever more pressure on operators, we ask whether councils are heading into dangerous territory by being too demanding

Published in Sports Management 2018 issue 2
Read on turning pages | Download PDF of this issue
Councils and contractors are having to find more creative ways to fund facilities / PHOTO: WILLMOTT DIXON ©
Councils and contractors are having to find more creative ways to fund facilities/ PHOTO: WILLMOTT DIXON ©

Local government leisure contracting is running into some interesting challenges as we head into the fourth decade of management contracts.

From a naive beginning in the late 80s with Compulsory Competitive Tendering, contracting has matured as a sector and now boasts a roster of serious players with vast operational expertise.

But do too many councils expect operators to step up and make the numbers add up for them, while putting pressure on them to perform? And if so, are the cracks starting to show?

Faced with the choice between signing up for an onerous 25 year contract, during which the council will expect escalating fees and the alternative – the freedom to compete on the open market – some operators are privately suggesting their management contracting days are numbered.

Why pay a penalty to a council for the right to operate a facility you can never own, when for far less investment, you can start your own business right over the road with no constraints.

If councils push too hard, they may spawn a whole new raft of competition, as management contractors throw in the towel and decide to compete instead.

And with only two main revenue streams – swim lessons and gym memberships, that competition would hurt badly.

Chris Marriott,

Director,

The Sports Consultancy

Chris Marriott
Chris Marriott

Local authorities could well be looking back on the last two to three years as somewhat of a golden period for them in terms of getting new sports and leisure centres built and funded.

Low rates of borrowing, combined with a very competitive operator market have made these new schemes affordable.

Some have questioned the sustainability of these “good times” given just how aggressively some of the operators have been bidding for the management contracts. We may well start to see some operators pull back a little now as they consolidate some of the contracts they’ve been winning, focusing on making sure they achieve those management fees they have committed to.

In the meantime, we’re starting to see some local authorities coming to the market being over-ambitious about what management fee they expect to achieve for their contract, perhaps influenced by conversations with a neighbouring authority which might have secured a stellar deal. However, when assessing the likelihood of getting a decent management fee, they need to take into consideration lots of different factors, such as whether the council is wanting to protect prices, whether it wants to protect various user groups and clubs, the split of maintenance responsibilities, etc. The more restrictions they place on a contract, the more it will cost them. Simple as that. They cannot have it all.

"The more restrictions councils place on a contract, the more it will cost them. Simple as that"

Councils expect contractors to use gym income to subsidise other services / © shuterstock/Syda Productions
Councils expect contractors to use gym income to subsidise other services / © shuterstock/Syda Productions

Steve Bambury,

Commercial director,

1Life

Steve Bambury
Steve Bambury

Over the past 10 years, the financial expectations placed on operators have increased significantly.

This is generally seen in either a considerably reduced fee for the operator’s services or a requirement for operators to pay a fee to the authority.

Increasing utility costs have created additional financial pressure when it comes to the performance of local facilities, while rising living costs and the growth of private sector ‘value’ offerings mean the customer is now expecting more for less.

Despite these pressures, councils still wish to maintain a significant interest in the operation of facilities, from programming and staffing through to core pricing and opening times. This often results in the local leisure centre not being on an even playing field with the competition from the private market, and this hampers the profitability of contracts.

A vast number of operators have already tested the private market in recent years, trying to find a niche that will ensure they’re less reliant on the local authority business. I think we’ll see some ringfencing their local authority operations completely, while most will be more selective in the contracts they bid for.

The private market provides great opportunities for operators to concentrate on their key strengths without the constraints of local authority buildings and contracts, allowing them to maximise their success.

"The private market provides a great opportunity for operators to concentrate on their key strengths without the constraints of local authority buildings and contracts"

Some management contractors are moving into the private sector
Some management contractors are moving into the private sector

Peter Gunn,

Chief executive,

BH Live

Peter Gunn
Peter Gunn

The open tender process can fall down when evaluation isn’t robust enough to identify clear gaps.

External consultants have a role to play in this process, by ensuring operators aren’t tempted to promise big savings simply because this is what councils want to hear.

Council contracts continue to be attractive, as most quality facilities are in public ownership. Certainly for us, as a social enterprise and registered charity, this is the most effective way of delivering our broader objectives – increasing participation and promoting the benefits of physical activity.

Profit isn’t the main motive, and I hope councils see the benefit of working with organisations which have shared goals.

If contracts are constructed correctly, with this shared ethos, there’s no reason why profit cannot flow from this. The difference for us is that all profits are reinvested into services and not distributed to shareholders. Either way, there can continue to be a ‘win-win’ for all involved.

However, it’s also important to diversify and not fall into the trap of entering into contracts that aren’t sustainable for either party and may have a relatively short tenure. For example, BH Live has set out to develop a small number of significant strategic partnerships with councils, based on long-term contracts covering theatre, conferencing, sport and leisure.

We also operate an event ticket agency, have JVs in catering and direct relationships with landlords for standalone gyms, to create commercial income streams to support our social objectives and allow us to invest more in the public sector facilities we operate.

"Profit is not the main motive, and I would hope councils see the benefit of working with organisations which have shared goals"

Justin Jardine,

Associate director,

GLL

Justin Jardine
Justin Jardine

GLL wants sport, leisure and wellbeing to be affordable and accessible for everyone in the community, achieving the mantra of ‘More People, More Active, More Often’. The current public sector leisure market is at a watershed moment in its efforts to achieve this goal.

We have to accept that the market is under increasing strain. Councils are facing significant financial pressure to deliver savings, and the market has become extremely competitive, due to the proliferation of low-cost gym operators.

Councils must ensure they’re getting best value for their services, but this shouldn’t be to the detriment of the social good which public services are there to provide for the public.

Leisure operators are already being very selective about the contracts they tender for due to a number of market factors, including reduced margins and over-ambitious starting points by councils and their advisors. However, many forward-thinking councils have decided to invest in their portfolios and set affordability thresholds in tenders that are realistic and achievable for operators, whilst protecting the important social value of those services.

Organisations, such as GLL, that predicted this shift in the market, have already diversified their business into services.

Our view is that this situation will persist until the public sector leisure market both consolidates and corrects itself over the next few years.

"The market has become extremely competitive due to the proliferation of low-cost gym operators"

John Bates,

Director,

Places for People Leisure

John Bates
John Bates

Places for People Leisure is aware that some local authorities are transferring an unacceptable level of risk to the leisure operator when outsourcing their leisure facilities.

The Sport England template that was established for use in the industry, which represents fair and equitable terms for both the council and the operator, is being excessively varied in some instances. This includes the removal of utility benchmarking and income benchmarking from the Benchmarking Schedule, which forces the operator to take full risk in both of these potentially volatile areas.

As a consequence, there’s likely to be a reduction in contractor appetite and, therefore, diminished competition.

We continue to look at opportunities in the local government outsourcing sector but also in the private sector, where shorter-term leases without the constraints of pricing controls and programming requirements can be more attractive than long-term leisure management contracts, which may have a greater risk profile.

"The Sport England template, which represents fair and equitable terms for both council and operator, is being excessively varied in some instances"

Operators are being asked to take all risk on utility bills, leaving them very exposed
Operators are being asked to take all risk on utility bills, leaving them very exposed

Duncan Jefford,

Regional director,

Everyone Active

Duncan Jefford
Duncan Jefford

Leisure is not a statutory service. Local authorities up and down the country are having to move from what was traditionally a service that cost money to one that generates revenue. And to do this, in the majority of cases, operators are now paying a managing fee to run the facility, rather than the operator receiving a managing fee.

I don’t think that councils are putting too much pressure on operators, however, they are asking for a bigger and bigger management fee from operators. There’s a frustration from an operator’s point of view, because we’re paying that management fee but we don’t necessarily have freedom on pricing and programming.

Unless we get real freedom in this area, we can’t always hit the level of income that the council is looking for under the contract.

As an operator, we’re not going to move away from council contracts. In fact, we think the local authority market is as buoyant as it’s ever been. But if councils want a bigger return, then the quality of facilities needs to be as good as it’s ever been, because it’s got to compete with the private sector. And secondly, we need to be given real freedom – the more freedom we have over the pricing and programming, the better position we’ll be in to pay councils more money.

"The more freedom we have over the pricing and programming, the better position we’ll be in to pay the council more money"

If councils want a return, then facilities have to match those in the private sector
If councils want a return, then facilities have to match those in the private sector

Have your say

If you have an opinion or new thoughts to add to the debate about council contracting, write to [email protected]

Sign up for FREE ezines & magazines
Sports jobs
Everyone Active
featured job

Swimming Teachers

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive hourly rate
Job location: Nationwide

Personal / Fitness Trainer - Glasgow Vinicombe Street

The Gym Group
Salary: Fantastic Benefits
Location: Glasgow, Scotland

Senior Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £19,775 per annum (39 hours a week pro rata)
Location: Cambridge, Cambridgeshire

Senior Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £19,775 per annum (39 hours pro rata)
Location: Chesham, Buckinghamshire

Class Instructors

Wiltshire Council
Salary: £15.38 - £26.25 per hour
Location: Amesbury, Salisbury, UK

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £18,305 per annum (39 hours a week pro rata)
Location: Gerrards Cross, Buckinghamshire

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £18,305 per annum (39 hours a weeks pro rata
Location: Chesham, Buckinghamshire

Personal / Fitness Trainer - Hemel Hempstead

The Gym Group
Salary: Fantastic Benefits
Location: Hertfordshire, England

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £18,305 per annum (39 hours a week pro rata)
Location: Hatfield, Hertfordshire

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £10.55 per hour
Location: Hackney, East London
recruiting with sports management

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £22,008 per annum (40 hours a week pro rata)
Location: Hackney, East London

Personal / Fitness Trainer - Birmingham Perry Barr

The Gym Group
Salary:
Location: West Midlands, England

Netball Coaches

Everyone Active
Salary: Competitive rate of pay
Location: South East, UK

Recruitment Open Day

GLL
Salary: Up to £22,008 per annum
Location: Lambeth, London, UK

Recreation Assistant (Lifeguard)

GLL
Salary: Up to £16,696 per annum
Location: Liskeard, Cornwall, UK

Duty Manager

Sylvestrian Leisure Centre
Salary: Competitive
Location: Snaresbrook, London, UK

Swimming Teacher

New Hall School
Salary: £20 - £25 per hour
Location: Boreham, Chelmsford, UK
recruiting with sports management

Lifeguard

New Hall School
Salary: £9.02 - £10.76 per hour
Location: Boreham, Chelmsford, UK

Saturday Swimming Teacher

New Hall School
Salary: £20 - £25 per hour
Location: Boreham, Chelmsford, UK

Graduate Boarding Assistants

New Hall School
Salary: £18,476
Location: Boreham, Chelmsford, UK

Lecturer in Cricket

Myerscough College
Salary: £20,657 – £29,880 per annum
Location: Preston, UK

Level 2 Swimming Teacher

Everyone Active
Salary: £14.50 per hour
Location: South Oxhey, Watford, UK

Level 2 Swimming Teachers

Everyone Active
Salary: £14.50 per hour
Location: South Oxhey, Watford, UK

Duty Manager

GLL
Salary: Up to £22,930 per annum (based on 39 hrs per week)
Location: Amersham, Buckinghamshire, UK
training with sports management

Duty Manager

GLL
Salary: Up to £25,655 per annum (based on 40 hrs per week)
Location: Kentish Town, London, UK

Health and Fitness Supervisor

GLL
Salary: Up to £23,894 per annum (based on 40 hrs per week)
Location: Redhill, Surrey, UK

Assistant Manager

énergie group
Salary: Competitive
Location: Basildon, UK

Fitness Instructor

énergie group
Salary: Competitive
Location: Basildon, UK

Duty Manager

GLL
Salary: Up to £25,655 per annum (based on 40 hrs per week)
Location: Thamesmead, London, UK

Swimming Instructors

Lex Leisure
Salary: Competitive
Location: Bexleyheath, UK

Recreation Assistants

Lex Leisure
Salary: Competitive
Location: Bexleyheath, UK
lifeguard jobs  swimming teacher jobs  recreation assistant jobs  apprenticeships jobs  personal trainer jobs  Gymnastics Coach jobs  duty manager jobs  assistant manager jobs  general manager jobs  assistant general manager jobs  Catering Assistant jobs  Customer Services Advisor jobs 
More jobs
Opinion
promotion
As an industry, we still underestimate the power of a truly varied fitness regime - and the growing appetite for it, especially among emerging customer segments.
Read more >
Opinion: Collaboration vs aggregation - what’s the difference?

Video Gallery

Wattbike
Introducing two new products to our commercial fleet.
Visit website
More videos

Company profile

Company profile: UK Trade & Investment
UK Trade & Investment is the government department that supports UK companies to trade internationally and helps overseas businesses to set up in the UK.
View full profile >
More company profiles

Featured Supplier

Join FitNation - the new fitness congress about innovation
FitNation, the new premier event about innovation in the fitness industry, will kick-off in Amsterdam on 4 October.
View full details >
More featured suppliers

Property & Tenders

Location:
Company: Kirklees Active Leisure
Location:
Company: Savills
More properties & tenders

Diary dates

15 Oct 2019
Loughborough University, Loughborough, United Kingdom
15-18 Oct 2019
Gran Via Exhibition Centre, Barcelona, Spain
28-30 Oct 2019
Hotel Royal Savoy, Lausanne, Switzerland
30-31 Oct 2019
NEC, Birmingham, United Kingdom
More diary dates